Comparison

What ED Medication Works Best? What the Evidence Says

Sildenafil and tadalafil sit at or near the top of the trial rankings, but the gaps are small. Timing, duration and safety limits usually decide the choice.

ED Treatments Compared editorial team · Updated · 7 min read

No single ED medication has been shown to work best for every man. The large trial reviews rank sildenafil and tadalafil at or near the top, with vardenafil close behind and avanafil lower, but the gaps are small, the rankings change with dose, and the pill that suits one man (fast onset, a long window, no food effect) is the wrong pill for another.12 What can be said is which drug fits which situation, and where the evidence for that is strong or thin.

What do the big trial reviews say about the best ED pill?

Four network meta-analyses, which compare drugs against each other indirectly through shared placebo trials, point the same general way without agreeing on a winner.

ReviewSizeWhat it found
Yuan 2013, Eur Urol118 trials, 31,195 menTadalafil seemed the most effective agent, followed by vardenafil; avanafil was less effective on one global question; no major safety difference between agents1
Chen 2015, Eur Urol82 trials for efficacy, 72 for adverse eventsSildenafil 50 mg had the greatest efficacy and the most adverse events; tadalafil 10 mg had intermediate efficacy and the lowest overall adverse event rate8
Madeira 2021, World J Urol179 trials, 50,620 menLow-dose sildenafil and tadalafil should be first options; avanafil was less effective9
Salonia 2026, J Sex Med83 placebo-controlled trials, 6,029 menOdds ratios versus placebo for satisfactory erectile function: sildenafil 100 mg 9.06, sildenafil 50 mg 7.90, vardenafil 10 mg 7.78, tadalafil 20 mg 7.13, avanafil 200 mg 3.42, tadalafil 10 mg 3.14, avanafil 100 mg 1.752

Two cautions apply. These are indirect comparisons across trials with different men, doses and outcome measures, so they are weaker than a head-to-head trial. And the 2026 review lists authors from Viatris, a drug company, which makes the generic and brand drugs it studied.2 Read the table as "all four work better than placebo, and the top three are close", not as a league table.

Is tadalafil or sildenafil better when they are compared directly?

Head-to-head trials mostly show a tie on effect and a preference for tadalafil. A meta-analysis of 16 trials that compared the two found similar efficacy and overall adverse event rates, with better psychological outcomes and a patient and partner preference for tadalafil. Myalgia and back pain were more common and flushing less common with tadalafil.3

The preference studies are open-label, meaning everyone knew which drug they were taking, so expectation can shape the answer. In a crossover study of 367 men, 71% of the 291 who completed both periods and chose preferred tadalafil.4 In a Chinese crossover study of 383 men, 69.1% of 350 completers preferred tadalafil 20 mg over sildenafil 100 mg.5 In a 90-man preference study of sildenafil, vardenafil and tadalafil, 52.2% chose tadalafil, 27.8% sildenafil and 20% vardenafil.10 The reason men gave most often for choosing tadalafil in the Chinese study was getting an erection long after taking the medication.5 That is a statement about the window, not proof of a stronger drug. The full pairwise breakdown is in our sildenafil versus tadalafil comparison.

Which ED pill fits which situation?

Because efficacy is close, the label differences in timing, duration and food are what most often settle the choice. All figures below are from the FDA prescribing information.

If the priority isThe label detail that mattersDrug
A long window with no timingImproved erectile function versus placebo up to 36 hours after an as-needed dose; terminal half-life 17.5 hours; absorption not influenced by food6Tadalafil
A well-known dose range with a mid-length windowTaken about 1 hour before sex (30 minutes to 4 hours allowed); terminal half-life about 4 hours; a high fat meal delays the peak by about 60 minutes11Sildenafil
A pill taken shortly before sexTaken as early as about 15 minutes before sexual activity at 100 or 200 mg; terminal half-life about 5 hours7Avanafil
A similar window to sildenafilTaken about 60 minutes before sex; terminal half-life 4 to 5 hours12Vardenafil

Two things the table cannot say. The label timing is the dosing instruction, not a guarantee that any one man will respond at that time. And a drug with a short half-life is not a weaker drug; it only leaves the body sooner.

Does the best ED medication change with age, heart disease or diabetes?

It can, mostly through safety limits rather than a different winner. Every approved ED pill is contraindicated with nitrates, and each label sets lower maximum doses with certain interacting medicines, liver problems or severe kidney impairment.116127 For example, the sildenafil label recommends 25 mg, no more than once in 48 hours, for men taking ritonavir, because it raised sildenafil blood levels 11-fold.11 The tadalafil label caps the as-needed dose at 10 mg in mild to moderate liver impairment and lowers it further in kidney impairment.6

These are reasons the choice belongs with a clinician who has the full medication list. They are also why a general ranking, including this one, cannot name a drug for a specific man. For men taking other medicines for blood pressure or the prostate, see our overview of ED treatment options.

What if the first ED pill does not help?

A single failed attempt is not a verdict on the drug. The sildenafil label notes that it has no effect without sexual stimulation, and that a high fat meal slows it.11 Dose is also adjustable: sildenafil can be moved between 25 mg and 100 mg, tadalafil between 5 mg and 20 mg and avanafil between 50 mg and 200 mg, based on response and tolerability, each no more than once a day.1167 Common next steps clinicians consider are a dose change, a different pill, or a different schedule, such as daily versus as-needed tadalafil. If one drug helps little at the highest labeled dose, other drugs are not ruled out, which is the question behind what might be better than tadalafil. Persistent trouble can also point to a cause that no pill treats, so it deserves a visit.

How to decide between ED pills

A short list works better than a ranking. Ask which matters most: a long window, a short onset, or a mid-length option many men already know. Ask whether meals, alcohol or other medicines are likely to interfere. Ask what the plan is if the first dose does not suit. And ask for an approved, labeled product where one exists. Compounded products are a separate topic, covered in our comparison of compounded and FDA-approved ED medications, because they have no label data on dose, food or timing.

Talk to a clinician. This article explains the evidence; it cannot tell you what is right for you. A licensed clinician who knows your health history and medications can.
Important safety information. PDE5 inhibitors (sildenafil, tadalafil, vardenafil) must not be taken with nitrates in any form, including nitroglycerin, or with guanylate cyclase stimulators such as riociguat, and need caution with alpha-blockers.11 The most common side effects are headache and flushing.11 An erection lasting more than four hours needs emergency care, and sudden loss of vision or hearing means stopping and getting medical help right away.6 Only a licensed clinician who knows your health history and medications should decide whether these are safe for you.

Frequently asked questions

Is there one ED medication that works best for everyone?

No. Network meta-analyses put sildenafil and tadalafil at or near the top, but the differences are small and the rankings change with dose and trial design.

Which ED pill lasts the longest?

Tadalafil. Its label reports improved erectile function compared with placebo up to 36 hours after an as-needed dose, with a terminal half-life of 17.5 hours.

Which ED pill acts fastest?

Avanafil is labeled to be taken as early as about 15 minutes before sexual activity, against about 60 minutes for sildenafil and vardenafil. Individual response varies.

Do men prefer tadalafil or sildenafil?

In two open-label crossover studies, 71% and 69.1% of men who chose a drug preferred tadalafil. Open-label means participants knew which drug they were taking.

Can a doctor change the dose or drug if the first one does not help?

Yes. Each label allows dose adjustment within a set range, and a clinician can also consider a different drug or schedule.

More comparisons

Part of our guide: ED Pills Compared: Sildenafil, Tadalafil, Vardenafil and Avanafil

Sources

  1. Yuan J, et al. Comparative effectiveness and safety of oral phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors for erectile dysfunction: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. Eur Urol. 2013. PubMed 23395275.
  2. Salonia A, et al. A comparative evaluation of on-demand phosphodiesterase-5 inhibitor efficacy in erectile dysfunction treatment: a systematic review and network meta-analysis of double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized trials. J Sex Med. 2026. PubMed 42296271.
  3. Gong B, et al. Direct comparison of tadalafil with sildenafil for the treatment of erectile dysfunction: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int Urol Nephrol. 2017. PubMed 28741090.
  4. Eardley I, et al. Factors associated with preference for sildenafil citrate and tadalafil for treating erectile dysfunction in men naïve to phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitor therapy: post hoc analysis of data from a multicentre, randomized, open-label, crossover study. BJU Int. 2007. PubMed 17552960.
  5. Bai WJ, et al. An open-label, multicenter, randomized, crossover study comparing sildenafil citrate and tadalafil for treating erectile dysfunction in Chinese men naïve to phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitor therapy. Asian J Androl. 2015. PubMed 25370206.
  6. Eli Lilly. CIALIS (tadalafil) prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.
  7. Metuchen Pharmaceuticals. STENDRA (avanafil) prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.
  8. Chen L, et al. Phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitors for the treatment of erectile dysfunction: a trade-off network meta-analysis. Eur Urol. 2015. PubMed 25817916.
  9. Madeira CR, et al. Efficacy and safety of oral phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitors for erectile dysfunction: a network meta-analysis and multicriteria decision analysis. World J Urol. 2021. PubMed 32388784.
  10. Tolrà JR, et al. Prospective, randomized, open-label, fixed-dose, crossover study to establish preference of patients with erectile dysfunction after taking the three PDE-5 inhibitors. J Sex Med. 2006. PubMed 16942534.
  11. Pfizer. VIAGRA (sildenafil citrate) prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.
  12. Lannett Company. Vardenafil hydrochloride tablets prescribing information. DailyMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine.